name: "Academic Research"
system_context: |
You are analyzing academic papers to map the intellectual landscape.
Your goal is to extract the structure of ideas — not bibliometric metadata.
Focus on:
- Which theories EXPLAIN which phenomena or findings
- Which findings SUPPORT or CONTRADICT which theories
- Which methods are USED to produce which findings
- Which systems IMPLEMENT which theories or methods
- Which researchers PROPOSED key theories, methods, or findings
Distinguish between abstract ideas and concrete artifacts:
- "Transformer" as an architecture is a THEORY
- "GPT-2" the trained model is a SYSTEM
- "reinforcement learning" is a METHOD
- "PPO" the algorithm is a METHOD
- "ChatGPT" is a SYSTEM
- Named benchmarks (GLUE, ImageNet) are SYSTEMs
entity_types:
CONCEPT:
description: "Core ideas, constructs, variables, technical terms"
extraction_hints:
- "Look for defined terms and key variables"
- "Use CONCEPT for ideas without named frameworks"
- "If it has a proper name and makes predictions, use THEORY"
THEORY:
description: "Named theoretical frameworks, models, paradigms"
extraction_hints:
- "Must have a proper name (e.g. 'Cognitive Load Theory')"
- "Include paradigms and schools of thought"
- "Note the originator or key proponents"
METHOD:
description: "Research methods, techniques, analytical approaches, tools"
extraction_hints:
- "Include study designs, analysis techniques, and instruments"
- "Capture software tools central to methodology"
FINDING:
description: "Key results, conclusions, effects, empirical observations"
extraction_hints:
- "Capture effect sizes and statistical significance"
- "Include null results and negative findings"
- "Use concise canonical labels (e.g. 'bilingual cognitive advantage')"
PHENOMENON:
description: "Observable events, behaviors, patterns being studied"
extraction_hints:
- "The real-world thing being investigated"
- "PHENOMENON is observable; CONCEPT is abstract; THEORY explains it"
- "Examples: 'urban heat island', 'antibiotic resistance'"
RESEARCHER:
description: "Individual academics credited with originating ideas"
extraction_hints:
- "Extract researchers attached to specific contributions"
- "Skip routine author mentions"
SYSTEM:
description: "Named systems, models, tools, artifacts built by researchers"
extraction_hints:
- "Use for specific implementations: BERT, GPT-4, ImageNet, SPSS"
- "SYSTEM is concrete; METHOD is abstract"
- "Include benchmarks and datasets with proper names"
FIELD:
description: "Academic disciplines, subfields, interdisciplinary areas"
relation_types:
SUPPORTS:
description: "Provides evidence for, validates, demonstrates effectiveness"
source_types: [FINDING, PUBLICATION, SYSTEM, METHOD, CONCEPT]
target_types: [THEORY, CONCEPT, FINDING, SYSTEM, METHOD, PHENOMENON]
CONTRADICTS:
description: "Provides evidence against, challenges, refutes"
source_types: [FINDING, PUBLICATION, SYSTEM, METHOD]
target_types: [THEORY, CONCEPT, FINDING, SYSTEM, METHOD]
review_required: true
EXTENDS:
description: "Builds upon or refines another entity"
source_types: [THEORY, CONCEPT, METHOD, SYSTEM]
target_types: [THEORY, CONCEPT, METHOD, SYSTEM]
IMPLEMENTS:
description: "System implements or is based on a theory/method/concept"
source_types: [SYSTEM]
target_types: [THEORY, METHOD, CONCEPT, SYSTEM]
USES_METHOD:
description: "Entity uses or employs a specific method/technique/system"
source_types: [PUBLICATION, FINDING, SYSTEM, METHOD, THEORY]
target_types: [METHOD, SYSTEM, CONCEPT]
EXPLAINS:
description: "Provides explanation, mechanism, or account for"
source_types: [THEORY, CONCEPT, METHOD, SYSTEM]
target_types: [PHENOMENON, FINDING, CONCEPT, METHOD, SYSTEM]
PROPOSED_BY:
description: "Entity originated from a researcher or publication"
source_types: [THEORY, CONCEPT, METHOD, FINDING, SYSTEM, PUBLICATION]
target_types: [RESEARCHER, PUBLICATION]